Welcome to the Fan Theory page! think you have something figured out? better post before someone else does!

(These are FAN theories, they may not be mine or everyone elses)

Older Theories on Top, Newer towards the Bottom.

WARNING! MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS!

If you would like to submit something for this page, please E-mail Moonclaw with your theory.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Tangleface of WindClan

Why I Believe the Jay/Leaf/Crow Theory

* Leafpool was getting noticeably fat- was it that she was only eating a lot, or bearing kits?

* Squirrelflights milk never came- what if they aren’t even her kits?

* Squirrelflight sure was early getting out of the nursery- usually queens need time to recover until their kits become apprentices. If she had kits, she would more than likely need time to recover before going back to her warrior duties.

* Jaypaw recalls in a dream about having to make a journey when he was a tiny kit. Leafpool confirmed the dream to be true. BOTH Leafpool and Squirrelflight were with him and his littermates. What if Leafpool and Squirrelflight went out of the hollow so that no cat would see Leafpool give birth to the kits, not Squirrelflight?

* While Jaykit, Hollykit and Lionkit were in the nursery, Leafpool would sometimes give them treats like honey. Jaykit thinks that she is trying to suck-up to them, maybe she is just giving treats to her kits because she must live a life as their Medicine Cat, not their mother.

* Think of Yellowfang and Brokenstar for a minute. Yellowfang was a medicine cat, therefore not allowed to have kits. Her son, Brokenstar was usually angry (I would imagine) and of course, ambitious. To me, that sounds a bit like Jaypaw, he always seems angry at something, and when he found out about the prophecy he sure did sound ambitious! What if that, his blindness, and other things not mentioned in the books that are out yet are punishment to Leafpool for having the kits?

* Now, think of their pelt colors. Jaypaw is a gray tom with burning blue eyes, Lionpaw is a golden colored tom with amber eyes, and Hollypaw is a black tabby she-cat. Now, where do you see gray or black pelts in Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight’s families? I sure don’t! What about Crowfeather’s family? He is descended from the great leaders Windstar and Gorsestar. Their pelt colors are: brown she-cat and gray tabby. Maybe Crowfeather’s fathers have a brown pelt? But it sure is more likely that Jaypaw got his gray pelt and blue eyes from Crowfeather!

* When Jaypaw wandered away from the Thunderclan camp, he walked into Windclan territory. He said that the wind felt oddly familiar and wonderful. Windclan cats love the wind and open moors- what if he is Crowfeather’s son, then the wind should feel like home to him like any Windclan cat!

* In the play (Warriors: Sunset: We Need to Talk), right when Crowfeather says that he and Nightcloud had Breezepaw as their kit, Leafpool immediately changes her mind about telling him SOMETHING. It’s likely that she was going to tell him that she was due for having kits, but since Crowfeather seems to have taken on another mate and ALREADY had kits, she’d not tell him.

* Leafpool has an unusually strong connection with Starclan- what if Jaypaw inherited his strong connection from Leafpool?

*Bluestar, Yellowfang and Lionheart came to Leafpool, showing her the 3 stars. Why would they show it to her, unless it has something to do with her? Plus, Firestar told no cat about his dream or meeting with Skywatcher, but Leafpool still acts wary of Jaypaw. Could she have interpreted her dream with the 3 stars to be her own children because she wasn’t really supposed to have them?

* Crow- a glossy black bird that has a harsh cry Jay- a noisy bird related to the crow but with brighter colors

Similar? Yup, also, Crowfeather (crowpaw at the time) was one described as “a dark smoky gray, almost black tom with blue eyes.” Jaypaw is just a gray tom with blue eyes, I guess he’s of lighter coloring than Crowfeather! * Some ask, "Why do Tigerclaw and Hawkfrost seem so interested in Jaypaw, Lionpaw and Hollypaw if their not kin?" Well, I'm confused at that too, But I would suspect that, as a Starclan cat is able to sense great power, cats from the dark forest can, too. Even though their not kin, Tigerstar WAS watching as Skywatcher gave his mysterious prophecy about Firestar's kin... he probably wants to use their power. Also, they would be looking for a chance to use Firestar's kin against him......

* In Firestar's Quest, EVERY SINGLE CHAPTER has the Leafpool picture on it! What if she's trying to tell the reader something... give them clues... you know, this is the book with the prophecy for the POWER OF THREE, what if Erin Hunter's trying to show a connection between Leafpool and the Prophecy? It the prophecy IS talking about Jaypaw, Lionpaw and Hollypaw, maybe it's trying to show that Leafpool has a "Special Connection" with them? * In Dark River, it says when Hollypaw goes missing that Leafpool seemed more worried than Squirrelflight- it maybe coincidence, but what if it's motherly worry? Squirrelflight's SUPPOSED to be Hollypaw's mother, why wasn’t she more worried? Leafpool's supposed to be calm about things (med. cat duty), why was she really worked up?

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Amberfur23

Why I belive the crowxleafxjay theory

there is a rumor going around that jaypaw mabey his siblings too are really leafpool's and crowfeather's children. I belive this theory! read this to see why!

1.Leafpool was getting noticeably fat, she might have been carrying kits. . .

2.squrrelflight's milk never came! they might not be her kits!

3.jaypaw had a dream that he was in the snow and leafpool said it was true, so that means leafpool would have had to come to had known. So mabe squrrelflight went out of camp so that no cat could see leafpool give birth!

4.squrrelflight got out of the nursery and back to warrior duties very quickly. . .did she have kits at all?

5.jaypaw's blind! could that be leafpool's punishment for having kits?

6.on the official site, there's a little scene called after sunset we need to talk, it's about a little chat leafpool has with crowfeather. She said she had to tell him something, but quickly stopped when he mentioned his new mate nightcloud. Could leafpool been trying to tell him she was expecting kits??

7.who in squrrelflight or brambleclaw's family is gray? one cat i know of: that's crowfeather!

8.some resemblance of jaypaw and crowfeather and leafpool

jaypaw's grumpy so is crowfeather

jaypaw has a strong connection with starclan so does leafpool

9.when hollypaw was missing in Dark River leafpool was very worked up . . . acting like her mother, and when hollypaw got back, she even thought leafpool was acting like her mother.

10.when jaypaw wandered into windclan territory her said it felt fimiliar, and wonderful. windclan cats love the moor so that could mean his father is crowfeather!

11.jays and crows are very similar, could that be some hint that crowfeather is his father

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Aurorastar

The Traitor

Hawkfrost claimed in Sunset that a traitor helped him out. There are a few possibilities for this:

1. Ashfur: This is one of the most common choices to date. He really didn't like Brambleclaw and felt that Squirrelflight abandoned him. He could've wanted to get back at them both by helping with Firestar's death. Also, it was Ashfur's apprentice Birchpaw who told Firestar that Blackstar was waiting for him. Also, Ashfur was with Firestar when Firestar got caught in the trap.

2. Birchfall? Birchpaw was the one who told Firestar that Blackstar wanted to talk...

3. Brackenfur: I recently heard this theory from someone else. Brackenfur was next in line for deputy until Leafpool was given the bramble sign. He may have been offended by the fact that the leader's daughter's mate was chosen deputy because of the other daughter's sign.

4. Spiderleg: Spiderleg is Ashfur's friend. He could've thought that getting back at Brambleclaw/Squirrelflight would cheer Ashfur up. He disagrees with Firestar and Brambleclaw many times in Dark River.

5. Hawkfrost? It is possible that there is no traitor. It was commented by Brambleclaw RIGHT before they discover Firestar in the trap that Hawkfrost smelled like ShadowClan. Hawkfrost could've tricked birchpaw into thinking he was a ShadowClan warrior. Then as he was dying may have told Brambleclaw that there was a traitor just to make his half-brother feel insecure.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Birdfeather

Frostfur's kits father (Frostfur's mate)

1) Lionheart: Lionheart is a golden tabby tom. Maybe Brakenfur and Thornclaw look like their father? (all golden tabby tom)

2) Redtail: this is the least popular, because that would mean Frostfur is Sandstorm's mother. But Brightheart is a tortoiseshell, and so is Redtail.

3) Darkstripe: Maybe... because Frostfur is a white queen, and Cinderpelt is a dark gray she-cat. She might look like her father

4) Runningwind: If he was so impaitient with apprentices, why was he gentle and understanding to Brakenpaw and Cinderpaw? Maybe because they are his children?

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Questseeker

The Firestar's Family-SkyClan connection and why I belive it

in Firestar's Quest that they describe Fawnstep as a "light brown tabby she-cat with a white chest and paws", don't you think that she looks kinda like Leafpool? So that could mean that Hollypaw,Jaypaw and Lionpaw already had SkyClan blood, even if Squirrelflight was mates with Ashfur. Whi I belive this, well... When Firestar and Sandstorm were looking at the pillar of stone, Firestar put his claws in, and they fit so perfectly that he could have made them himself. So that could mean that Firestar is descended from when SkyClan fled, or that one of Spottedpelt's or Gorseclaw's descendants left ThunderClan, to live as a kittypet. That would also explain how Firestar once had dreams of the forest when he was a kittypet,and why he left to join them, and felt so at home. With Sandstorm, It could be that Redtail or her anonymous mother was descended from the SkyClan cats that stayed, again Birdflight, Spottedpelt or Gorseclaw. If that's the case, then Sandstorm is also connected with Tigerstar! Which would mean that either way, wheather Brambleclaw or Ashfur, Hollypaw, Jaypaw and Lionpaw could be Tigerstar-and therefore Hawkfrost's- kin.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Sunfoot1

Here it is! Ok we all know who is the father of sandstorm,but have you ever wondered who is the mother of sandstorm?

Well here are some guesses 1)This is the most popular (to me at least)GOLDENFLOWER because they look alike(sandstorm and goldenflower)

And also tigerstar/tigerclaw could have killed Redtail not only to become leader but to become Goldenflowers mate.But there is something

cool brambleclaw is related! 2)Mousefur might be the mother of sandstorm.she is one of the oldest cats and so is sandstorm but mousefur

is an elder so it is possible 3)ONE-EYE could be the mate of redtail and the mother of sandstorm 4)IT COULD ALL BE A MYSTIORIY WE NEED TO FIND OUT ON OUR OWN!

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Sunfoot1

You all know that when Tawnypaw was still an apperentice,she left Thunderclan and went to Shadowclan.One reason was because she belived no cat liked her because of her father. But there could be other reason. Like:

1)She could have liked someone over on Shadowclan While seeing them at a Gathering.

2)She could have liked the territory better.

3)Maybe she got a dream from Starclan saying to live there.

4)She could have wanted to be with her father.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Sunfoot1

Sunfoot1: What if some how Squirrelflight and Hawkfrost really ad a kit? If the did I think it is the cat on the cover of Dark River Heatherpaw.

Well if they did have Heatherpaw this is why I believe so:

1)She has a golden pelt like Squirrelflight's

2)She has ICE BLUE EYES a little like Hawkfrost's

3)She seems to have an AMBISIOUS(sp) personality like Hawkfrost did

4)She sometimes can be a snot!like Squirrleflight

5)Hawkfrost could have sent her to Windclan so no one would know it was his kit

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Sunfoot1

Do you remember who Crowfeather's mother was?Well if you don't it is Ashfoot so now that you know that lets see if there are possible anwsers to who was his father

1)Deadfoot.In the books it says that Deadfoot is a black tom.Crowfeather could have gotten his ALMOST black pelt from him.

2)Webfoot.The book says he is a dark gray tom a little like Crowfeather

3)Tornear.They may not look alike but they both have the same attitude.

4)Rushtail.It is almost inpossible that he is the father cause 1 he is a light colored tom 2 his first apperince is in Starlight and 3 he is an elder

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Sunfoot1

How did Lionpaw,Hollypaw,And Jaypaw get there fur color?

Lionpaws Fur:It is golden,Like his mother's,grandmother's,and grandfather's.

Hollypaw's Fur:It's black,Like Leafpool's tabby stripes,and like Brambleclaw's tabby stripes.

Jaypaw's Fur:Well Jaypaw is blind so he is different,so maybe thats why he is gray.Or maybe he is really the son of Crowfeather and Leafpool.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Tawnyflight/Hawkmask

1. Everyone thinks Jaypaw is Crowfeathers and Leafpool's kit but what about Hollypaw its their kit so wouldn't it be mixed?

2. Why did Leafpool feel so disappointed when Hollypaw became a warrior.

3. Hollypaw wanted to be like Leafpool most kits like to be like their parents.

4. Hollypaw is a bit barbed-tounge who does that remind you of? Crowfeather!

5. Hollypaw also cares about her siblings just like Leafpool and Squirrelflight!

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Butterflywind

Have you ever wondered who Firestar’s mother was?

Well one day I was reading the secrets of the clans, and it hit me! I think Firestar’s mother was barleys sister!

Think about it, she is gingery red, and barley is brown and white witch would explain why princess is the color she is.

But the only other explanation I see would be that she also could have been sandstorms mother, I mean why else would Erin Hunter

put that story in the book? You think about it, and I’ll get back to you on that.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Silverbrook

Erin Hunter says one of the kits is going to be evil...

JAYPAW is grumpy, but I don't think he's interested in being leader or anything.

LIONPAW just seems to dumb to do anything of the kind; if anything, he'd accidentally betray his Clan

HOLLYPAW is just too smart, too good at fighting for her own good.

Hollypaw is the type who can justify everything and make everything seem reasonable. So, she might end up deluding herself into thinking its for the good of the Clan.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Silkytail

What if Hollypaw, Jaypaw, and Lionpaw wer the children of Squirrelflight and Ashfur!

Squirrel never really loved Bramble!

Bramble might not know cuz Squirrel told him the kits were his!

Hollypaw looks like Ashfur

Jaypaw looks like Ashfur

and Lionpaw looks like Squirrelflight!

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Silkytail

why i believe the crowxjayxleaf rumor

in the play after sunset we need to talk leafpool needs to talk with crowfeather

she never got the chance cuz a soon as crow said he had a mate she stopped

then all of a sudden jaypaw is born! he looks just like crow and nothing like squirrel or bramble

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Silverfog

Which of the three will be evil?

Jaypaw; He could be (well, it's 1 chance in 3) but I don't think so. He's bitter, but he's already turned down Tigerstar and Hawkfrost to follow Spottedleaf, and it said that he didn't trust them. If he was the evil one, I think that he'd probably have trusted them over Spottedleaf.

Hollypaw; She's a little more likely to me, simply because she's very ambitious. She has dreams of becoming Clan leader. She's also very smart; Brambleclaw calls her 'my little thinker'. If she had evil plans, they'd be very likely to succeed. But, she's also very loyal to the Clan, and to the warrior code. She'd be more likely to think twice before murdering for power.

Lionpaw; I think that he's the most likely. He's already met with Tigerstar and Hawkfrost, and seems to trust them quite well. In fights, he enjoys hurting and winning...

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Wildpath

Lionpaw is squirrleflights son no dought about it. he never remembered traveling in the snow like jaypaw did. Maby he was safe and sound in the nursery while squirrleflight was picking up hollykit from leafpool who had to have kits outside so no cat saw her.

hey, yellowfang pulled it off! Hollykit has black fur like our freinds crowfeather and nightcloud.

BUT... if you go to the website (www.warriorcats.com), you can read the after sunset play LEAFPOOL, wants to talk to crowfeather. Was it to say goodbye or to say SHE was having HIS kits?!?

Now to Jaykit. I believe he is stormfurs kit. But you think then he would not be related to firestar. This took a lot of research but it says swiftpaw is graystripes brother in the family lines. and in his mourning serimony, GOLDENFLOWER his MOTHER mourned for him. means bramblclaw is graystripes kin, brambleclaw is firestars kin, firestar is stormfurs kin, and jaypaw is his kins kin

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Icepool

Why i do not beleve the CrowXLeaf=Jay theory

* Tigerstar was interested in Jaypaw he wouldnt be interested if he wasnt related

* Sandstorm had the same problem Squirrelflight did with her milk

* Someone would have said something

* Crowfeather and Leafpool did'nt spend enough time alone to have kits

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Duskmoon

Graystripe x Cinderpelt Theory

This is why I believe Graystripe and Cinderpelt are related:

1. Cinderpelt- Dark Gray she-cat Graystripe- Dark gray tom with a black stripe along his spine Similar?

2. Graystripe is one of the only other gray cats in the clan at the time. Could Cinderpelt have gotten her gray fur from his genes in her bloodline?

3. Graystripe is always friendly and close nit with Cinderpelt. Could it be because they are relatives?

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Birdfeather

Leafpool's dream (Sunset, pg. 102)

-You will tread a path no medicine cat has walked before you: This means that Hollypaw, Lionpaw, and Jaypaw cannot be her kits! Yellowfang had Brokenstar, and if her path is going to be 'never walked before' it must be something else...

-There are cats you have left to meet, yet your paws will shape their destiny: Maybe she is very important to Hollypaw, Lionpaw, and Jaypaw somehow...

I don't think that the three (Hollypaw, Lionpaw, and Jaypaw) are Leafpool's kits! Squirrelflight is continually looking over Jaypaw (licking him, nuzzling him, grooming his fur) and Brambleclaw is quite fond of Hollypaw and Lionpaw! Also you don't have to look like a family member to be related. Where does gray and black (Rainwhisker and Sootfur) come from in Sorreltail's family?

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Cloverleaf

Why Crowfeather Doesn't Like Breezepaw:

1. Maybe he secretly hates Nightcloud, who is possessive. Breezepaw is like Nightcloud, so maybe he sees her in him.

2. He knows Lionpaw, Hollypaw, and Jaypaw are his kits and thinks that they're perfect and can't claim them as his offspring...but he can claim poor Breezepaw, who is quite pathetic in every way possible, and he doesn't want to do that, so he is mean to Breezepaw.

3.(Kind of out there) Maybe Breezepaw isn't really his son and he knows it...

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Leafstar

Firestar's Mother and Brother

I've seen a theory about Violet being Firestar's mother, and it seemed believable, but I pondered this for MANY days, and I may sound CRAAAAZY, but listen...

I think Firestar's mother is Quince, the mother of Tiny aka Scourge.

1. Quince's mate, whose name we don't know, had ginger fur. Quince herself, looking at a picture of her mate on the Twolegs' shelf, said,'You would have been proud of your kits, my love. Strange that none of them have your ginger fur... But I see your spirit in them just the same.' Doesn't Firestar have ginger fur? Spirit? It's not just the mother that passes on traits!

2. Most people think that Quince's mate died. Maybe he left, then came back after Socks, Ruby, and Tiny were gone. So it's possible he fathered Firestar. Hey, everyone thought Graystripe had died, and where is he now?

3. Scourge was a kit of probably less than six moons when Tigerstar was an apprentice. Once Scourge became a big baddie in his middle seasons, Tigerstar was a senior warrior, as he was when Firepaw came to the forest. Back it up six moons, its still possible that Firestar is Scourge's younger brother.

4. And what about Firestar's confirmed sister, Princess? Maybe Quince is colored like Princess?

We may never know. But why would Erin Hunter insert that scene in the Rise of Scourge if it had no connection with any major characters or any cat in the Rise of Scourge? Something to ponder.

If you recieve Erin's Authortracker, you may have read this section of the newsletter:

In our last letter, we hinted that if you read The Rise of Scourge carefully, you might discover the most shocking secret EVER in the history of Warriors. Have you figured it out yet?

What if they're talking about Quince and her mate possibly being Firestar's parents, making Scourge, the most evil, bloodthirsty rouge ever known, noble Firestar's older brother? Nothing else very mysterious about the book, aside from explaining Scourge's etchy past

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Mysticpool

Here's my thing I pointed out before which is an exherp from COTC:

But one thing Leafpool did not forsee was falling in love-and with a WindClan warrior at that. Yes, Adderkit, I'm sure WindClan warriors are the best of all, but Leafpool was a medicine cat! Everything about their relationship was wrong according to the warrior code. How could their love lead to anything but misery and ill forutne? Even now it echoes among the Clans, coloring their future in ways not even Leafpool can see.

Also something occurred to me earlier. A couple people pointed out that Yellowfang is like Jaypaw, Bluestar is like Hollypaw and Lionheart is like Lionpaw. Here's my thing. Bluestar had halfClan kits. Yellowfang had forbidden kits. Perhaps pointing to Leafpool's having Crowfeather's kits?

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Silverleaf

Have you ever wondered where Hollypaw, Jaypaw, and Lionpaw got their powers?

1.Lionpaw got his fighting talents form Tigerstar and Hawkfrost (of course)

2.Hollypaw got her hunting skills from Sandstorm, her grandmother.

3.Jaypaw could have gotten his ability to sense other cats' feelings from Squirrelflight and Leafpool's special bond. The rest is a mystery..........

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: ? A fan Ok first of all CrowxLeaf theory is untrue because Erin would have said something about. and they wouldn't just do that.

They dont have to look like the other members of thier families to be part of the family( example: Snowkit- white tom. Speckletail pale tabby. Smallear Gray tom)

Hollypaw could have got her black pelt from from the tabby stripes on her fathers pelt.

Lionpaw looks like his Fathers uncle Lionheart (golden brown tom)

Jaypaw Why does everyone think hes the son of Leaf and Crow? the authors wouldn't do something that drastic. Anyway he could have got his blue eyes from being blind. and His gray fur could have gotten from his great grandfather Smallear and tabby stripes from his father.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Hazelpool

I have a fan theory about how Squirrelflight got that giant wound on her belly.

Okay, so sandstorm said that Squirrelflight was fighting beside her, and no windclan or riverclan warrior gave her that wound,

and later, after Squirrelflights wound, it says Ashfur still had blood on his paws, but what if it was FRESH blood, maybe HE gave Squirrelflight that wound while no one was looking?

Its also proof he is evil and is the cat who helped Hawkfrost, or maybe he just wanted to get back at Squirrelflight for dumping him, who knows...

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Gentletail

Why does everybody think that Ashfur helped Hawkfrost try to kill Firestar?

I mean, think about it. Ashfur hates Brambleclaw for taking Squirrelflight, so why would he help Brambleclaw become leader?? I have no idea who did help Hawkfrost, but it wasn't Ashfur, that's for sure!

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Petalstar

I believe the 'Ashfur is the traitor in Sunset' theory because:

He could have been getting even with Squirrelflight for picking Brambleclaw, by helping Hawkfrost kill her father.

He hates Lionpaw- Squirrelflight's son.

Is grumpy throughout 'Power Of Three'

Hardly cares about training Lionpaw.

Brambleclaw acts uneasy around him, and when he was talking to Lionpaw, he seemed to know who the tratior was.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Duskstalker

Why I DON'T believe Ashfur was the traitor:

okay, this is why i totally freaked when I first heard the theory. no one seems to notice but ashfur hates brambleclaw. so if he was the traitor he would have been helping brambleclaw becoem leader, which would be weird.

another point: some people point out that he hates lionblaze... but that wouldn't have anything to do with it because lionblaze wasn't born then!!!

also, during twilight when we really get to know ashfur, he is always the one STOPPING squirrelflight from leaping at brambleclaw and tearing his throat out.

not only does this point to a decidedly non-violent nature, it would seem weird for him to turn around and try to kill firestar, which would probably lead brambleclaw to suicide.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Silverbrook

1. Ashfur could have done it with Hawkfrost to spite Squirrelflight for "leaving" him by killing her father. I know many people disagree with the Ashfur is Traitor theory because that would mean Brambleclaw would be leader, but what if he had a deal with Hawkfrost: Hawkfrost would kill Firestar AND Brambleclaw, and then once he had taken over the forest, he promised Ashfur the position of deputy if Ashfur helped him. And whose apprentice was it that TOLD Firestar that Blackstar was on the territory? There is a con side to this, though, why would Ashfur come back and TELL Squirrelflight that Firestar was in a trap? That part makes no sense, unless he wanted Squirrelflight and Leafpool to die at the paws of Hawkfrost, too! Although Firestar obviously trusts him, he gave him Lionblaze (Brambleclaw's son!) to mentor. And how come he's so nice to Brambleclaw now? Maybe he's hoping to catch him off-guard...

2. Brackenfur could have done it because, like Aurorastar said, he knew he was next-in-line to become deputy (it was common knowledge), but then Leafpool got the sign, which meant that the leader's daughter's sign meant the other daughter's mate should be deputy. He was smart enough not to challenge Firestar's decision and Leafpool's sign, because that would automatically point to him as the traitor. Also, if you ask me... Brackenfur is too good, he's like a goody-goody. He's the perfect mate, father, and mentor. Everyone likes him and trusts him, including Firestar. He was smart enough to leave tracks behind that pointed to Ashfur rather than him. Like Ashfur, he might have made the deal to take out Brambleclaw at the same time in order for him to be leader of ThunderClan, or deputy when Hawkfrost took over.

3. Sorreltail? It's highly doubtful, but she IS Brackenfur's mate, but Leafpool is also her best friend. Would she do that to her best friend? And also she had kits and was in the nursery... it'd be awfully difficult for her to pull off, and I don't think she did it. But things are not always what they seem...

I don't think there's another option; it's doubtful that Hawkfrost (smart as he is) could have done it alone, which means there has to be a traitor. I'm not sure whether I believe Ashfur or Brackenfur did it. Maybe both of them helped! That would mean Brambleclaw is surrounded by two traitors, and two of his supposed kits got trained by them!

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Hopegaze of Thunderclan

Why i DONT beleve the LeafxCrow=Jay theory

1) I read somewhere, i think in The Sight prologue, that Firestar was watching Squirrelflight pregnant licking Brambleclaw behind the ear! And firestar, in his head said, "the three has come"

2) If you go to warriorcats.com and click participate then ask erin hunter, someone asked"there are rumors that one or more of the kits- espeically Jaypaw- are secretly the children of Leafpool and Crowfeather. What do you make of this?" then, Erin hunter answers: "It's an interesting rumor but i really could'nt comment..." You see! she never even thought of that!

3) Why does everyone think that if a cat has the same color pelt like another cat, their related?! I mean C'mon!

4) Look, how do you guys even know that Leafpool was noticibly fat!?

5) I believe that Quince (Scourge's mother) is Firestar's mother. She was Grey right? So maybe Jaypaw got his pelt color from her.

6) I remember in the biggining of The sight they say that Squirrelflight's milk never came, If you now Science, t have milk,you need lots of protein in your body! Maybe Leafpool diddn't have a good supply of Borage that time! Or, she was jealos that Squirelflight had kits and she doesn't so she didd'nt give her sis enough!

7) When Yellowfang had her kits she had three. (You will know if you read Secrets of the clans) two she-cats and one tom. one of the she-cats was born dead, and the other she-cat eventully died while the tom, brokenstar survived. The two she-cats died, but that was'nt the punishment, what was the punishment? That brokenstar lived. So think of Jaypaw, if he was born by Leafpool he would be hated by all (if they knew) Starclan hated brokenstar but Jaypaw, lionpaw, and hollypaw (they are warriors now) are in a PROPHECY!!

8) in dark river when hollypaw was missing. leafpool was so scared more than sguirrelflight because Sqiurrelflight knows hollypaw better than leafpool cause shes her mom, so she knows that hollypaw ran off herself!

9) to Tangleface of windclan, he said that EVERY SINGLE CHAPTER there was a picture of leafpool in Firestar's Quest and it must be a sighn from erin hunter. well, i checked my shelf and opened the book and every single chapter was FIRESTAR not LEAFPOOL!

10) even if every single chapter was leafpool, it would make sense ,like, i dont know SpottedLEAF and LEAFstar!

11) Now, in outcast and when he felt the wind and said he liked it, so you think he said that because his father was a windclan warrior, well, the mountains is farter away from windclan. the mountains were calling him becuase he has to go save them from the intruders!

12) ok, when Jaypaw thought of walking through snow was because he was born in leafbare. Duh........

13) that's why tigerstar are interested in Jaypaw and lionpaw because they are brambleclaw's kits not because they'll help them, there are more better apprentices to pick on!

14) In eclipse when millie finished giving birth Jaypaw said '' That was amazing!'' Then Leafpool said in a small voice, ''yes, yes it was" and in Jaypaw's mind said "does she ever want kits?'' You see, she wants kits but doesn't have. If she did have she would be happy, because her kit is right next to her!

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Ardvarkstar When Leafpool, and Jaypaw are looking for herbs, Leafpool looks at Jaypaw in a motherly way and says "I've always believed in you."

When the apprentices go missing (Into the underground tunnels) Leafpool is more worried then Squirrelflight was.

I think Erin was giving off a hint when both Crowfeather's and Jaypaw's name began with birds. Maybe thats why Jaypaw was names that. Jaypaw remembers a journey through the snow- the time he was born.

Crowfeather likes Jaypaw more then Breezepaw.

In "Sunset We need to talk" Leafpool needs to tell Crowfeather something, until he mentions his new mate and kits.

It says Squirrelflight's milk never came

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Dusky

Lioblaze or Hollyleaf will fall in love with one of Graystripe's new kits (or at least I hope so!)

Both Hollyleaf and Lionblaze don't really have crushes on anyone, but Lionblaze is going sort of evil, so it might be Hollyleaf. Lionblaze could become mates with either Blossomkit or Briarkit, maybe one of them could turn him good again! Hollyleaf could become mates with Bumblekit. She needs a tom in her life. I thought this would be awesome if it happened because I LOVE Graystripe. I suppose Jaypaw could fall in love with Briarkit or Blossomkit also, but it's more unlikely.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Duskstalker

Who is Graystripe's mom? The family trees say Willowpelt, which would make sense because of her pelt color, but when she has Sorrel, Rain, and Soot, it is repeatedly stated that they are her first litter. Other possibilities:

1) Brindleface: She is a tabby, and tabbys can produce virtually any color cat -- it's in their genes.

2) Bluestar: It's a long shot, but Bluestar didn't bury Mosskit, did she? She just scraped some snow over him and continued to save Misty/Stone. So maybe Mosskit woke up, and by some miracle found his way back to camp? Or maybe she had a 4th kit we don't know about...

3) Graypool: OK, I know it's an even longer shot than Bluestar. But remember when Graystripe is meeting with Silverstream, and later when he goes to RiverClan to be with Feather/Storm? He adapts so quickly to the water. His fur becomes silky and sheds water quickly. This could be a sign of RiverClan heritage, especially when he turns out to be such a good swimmer. Later, Mistyfoot says to Firestar (then Fireheart) that he is decent at catching fish.

Here's an extension on that theory: It always confused me that none of the five apprentices at the time were siblings, because normally cats have more kittens then most of the fictional Clan cats have. And Graystripe never had a problem with standing up to Sandstorm when she was being mean. So maybe they are littermates? Oakheart could have been their father. That would be a nice bit of irony, Graypool having Oakheart's kits when she also has to pretend that his kits by Bluestar are hers.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Iceleaf

I was reading Forest of Secrets and I realized Tigerstar's father was HALFTAIL! Thier appearances match exactly, and when tigerstar's exile was pronouced it said a elder let out a long wail.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Echofire

I saw other people's ideas of who are Firestar's parents, and I just had a REALLY brilliant idea of who Firestar's parents could REALLY be!

Well other someone else's idea was that Scourge could be Firestar's brother because of Scourge's father's pelt, which is red, and another person's idea was that Barley's sister, Violet, could be Firestar's mother, and then I realized that Violet could be Firestar's mother because her pelt is red and her brother Barley 's pelt is brown and white, like Princess, and and Scourge's father could be Firestar's father because his pelt is also red!

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Mossmask

In the fourth series, 'The Fourth Apprentice' (I know this is kind of obvious and most of you have guessed it already anyway, but I don't care) We already know that Leafpool and Crowfeather are the parents of Jayfeather, Hollyleaf, and Lionblaze. I think that 'The Fourth Apprentice' (who won't be revealed until the VERY LAST line of Sunrise) will be the third cat it the prohpecy. I think this because Lionblaze has amazing fighting skills, and Jayfeather is phsycic, but Hollyleaf has absolutely NO talent whatsoever, she just likes to 'follow the rules', which actually ends up working against her than for her most of the time anyway. If the fourth apprentice really is the last prophecy cat, then it would have to be one of Firestar's kin. I'll explain this theory in more depth below.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Mossmask

This one I haven't seen ANYWHERE on the web before (though it's gotta be out there somewhere) so anyway, when we found out that Scourge was firestar's half brother (gasp!...not) we weren't too surprised, (or at least the obsessee's) but either way, it was hard to see what that would mean for the series... Scourge is dead, so Firestar will never even know? How could this come into play at all? Weeeelll... Last book of Warriors: Firestar kills his half brother.

Last book of The New Prophecy: Brambleclaw kills his half brother.

My prediction: Last book of The Power of Three: Lionpaw kills his half brother (Breezepaw)

I came to beleive this after thinking that: Obviously, the first two books set the half brother-half brother pattern. They wouldn't have bothered mentioning Scourges father and making that very first connection unless there was a reason. That was it. Who in ThunderClan has a halfbrother? Leafpool's kits. It couldn't be Hollyleaf. If it were Half brother-half sister, they could have easily used Princess (being Firestar's sister means that she was also Scourges' half sister) in the New Prophecy, there were always Mothwing or Tawnypelt, the option of making a boy girl connection was always out there, but it's always been boy-boy. That means no Hollyleaf. That left me with Lionblaze and Jayfeather. Not only is Jayfeather a medicine cat, but he just doesn't strike me as the kind of cat that would do such a thing. That leaves Lionblaze. now this leads us back to why the fourth Apprentice isn't breeze or Tiger. Lion we know for certain is a prophecy cat. Breeze we only suspected. That means, that it can't be Breeze kills Lion, because they can't kill off the prophecy cats. That would ruin the whole point of the whole TeaPot series. So now, with breezepaw dead, that only leaves Tiger as the Fourth Apprentice runner up. But wait. HE'S NOT FIRESTAR'S KIN! He is related, but not kin. He's Firestar's daughter's mate's sister's kit. That means he's the kits.. great uncle, I think. either way, although he's related, it's not by blod. That means he isn't actually kin to Firestar. That means that the forth Apprentice has to be truly Squirrel and Brambles, but they haven't had kits yet, wich means that The Fourth Apprentice hasn't been born yet. There is one thing about the second theory that I caught though... on the last book of Warriors the cover has Firestar, and the nezt series' last book has Hawkfrost. Both those cats are involved in the half-kill-half patter, (let's call it the Half- Pattern, or H- Pt). On the last book of TeaPoT, is Hollyleaf... coincodence... I think so, but I'm putting it out there because every piece of evidence helps, and it might be useful in future refrences

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Mossmask + Silent Memento

The Erins disregarded all of the clues that they'd laid down to appease the fans. Yep, Ashfur is the traitor and gets murdered for no reason other than the Brambleclaw/Squirrelflight fans being mad at him. Here's the real traitor: Spiderleg. Look at these reasons:1. Ashfur could've never made contact with Hawkfrost. He was stuck in the camp under Leafpool's care in most of the sixth, and he was wrapped up in Squirrelflight in the fifth. That means that the latest he could've made a plan was in the fourth, and Hawkfrost's plan in the fourth was to take over WindClan.

2. Ashfur fought alongside them at the battle in Starlight. Spiderleg was sent to watch the ShadowClan border. The latter was nowhere near the action. Not to mention the fact that he was the first to want to chase Mistyfoot out.

3. Spiderleg seemed desperate to get out of camp in the sixth. He practically begged Leafpool to check his injuries.

4. Spiderleg was on patrol when Firestar was nearly killed, and Ashfur seemed literally freaked out. You can't fake fear scent.

5. When Firestar announced that Spiderleg was sitting his vigil, the moon was slightly covered and an eerie wind rushed through the Gathering. Rather coincidental?

6. In the fifth Wands and Worlds chat Vicky said to 'keep a look out on Ashfur, who is a great warrior who's been through so much, getting a mate'. Spiderleg is the traitor, and Ashfur got framed.

That's sort of a theory.. it's not something I think will happen in the future (duh) but I think that the Erins were dropping hints leading to this, but then when the fans started flaming Ashfur, decided to make him the traitor instead, just to appease a bunch of BramblexSquirrel fans.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Leopardpath

Spoiler if any of you have read Long Shadows, you should know what Squirrelflight tells her "kits" because in the end of the book, squirrelflight tells Ashfur and the three that Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather are not her kits, witch makes the three think that they aren't the three in the prophecy, but I bet they are because why would Erin Hunter focuse all of the 3ed warriors series on them. But it is probably true that Squirrelflight isn't their mother, because remember, in the first power of three book it say that ferncloud nursed Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze when Squirrelflight's milk didn't come, and in the book it never mentions Sqirrelflight nursing them, and it also say that Sqirrelflight continued to be on warrior dutys while the three were kits. But how, how could they be the three, because the three have to be Firestar's grandchildren? I think that Squirrelflight was just saying that she was the three's mother because the real mother was not suppose to have kits, and because the pair that had them were forbidden to have kits together,makeing it real forbiden love. Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, and Lionblazes Mother and father would have to be...... Leafpool and Crowfeather! Because they could still be the three because Leafpool is Firestar's daughter, and in the second seres of warriors, leafpool and crowfeather run away because they loves each other so much and they were forbidden to be mates. And when they ran away, they probably did you know what, but leafpool didn't think that she would have kits and when she found out that, she ask her sister Squirrelflight to pretend to be their mother, and because she knew of the prophecy she must have knew that Her kits were the three and she had to give them to her sister instead of one of the nursing queens because then if she did give them to the queens, there would be no possible way for even a cat who knew about the prophecy to think that they were the three. And Crowfeather doesn't even like his new mate, probably because he can't let go of the fact that he loves Leafpool. I looked at a few pictures of warrior cats, including Crowfeather, Leafpool, Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze and you can see that Hollyleaf and Jayfeather get their colors from Crowfeather, and Lionblaze gets his from his grandparents, Firestar and Sandstorm. And I just thought of this that because Jayfeather was leafpool's Med. cat apprentice, and leafpool named him, Get it JayFEATHER and CrowFEATHER so she named him in honor of his father that Jayfeather didn't know that crowfeather was even his father. I think that that' s how they could actually be the three. And since Leafpool is a Med. cat, and like Yellowfang something bad would happen. I don't think it's Jayfeather, I think It's Lionblaze because He's undefeat able in battle and he might go over board.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Foxwhisker

Ashfur's dealth:

MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS!!!! DON"T READ IF YOU HAVEN"T READ "LONG SHADOWS"

I beleive that Leafpool killed Ashfur some reason. I don't have many reasons why, I just think that. At the end of "Long Shadows" Ashfur is found dead in the water, after leaving early for the gathering to reveal Squirrelflight's secret: '"The Three" aren't her kits.' Here's why:

1. I think the book was trying to make it look like Squirrelflight killed him.

2. He was found in the water- a good place for Leafpool since she looks there for herbs. Plus she could have used that as an excuse to sneak out of camp when Ashfur left to go to the gathering early.

3. I also think this because I think "The Three" are Leafpool's kits. She didn't want anyone to know that the kits weren't Squirrelflight's either.

4. Some freinds of mine who also read the books think Squirrlflight killed him because of the last page of "Long Shadows." And like usual I have to disagree with them.

5. It just seems like a thing Erin Hunter would put in the story line...

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Wildfire of RiverClan

Why Ashfur was the traitor:

I think that Ashfur had occassional fits of madness. During these fits he would do things without really knowing what he was doing, like betray Firestar. As the books go on, these fits increase. Eventually he just completely lost it. I do not think that he should go to the Dark Forest because he was a truly loyal cat, he just could not fight the madness

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Goldenriver

Potential bloodlines for Jaypaw, Hollypaw, and Lionpaw.

Couldn't Lionheart be Sandstorm's father instead of Redtail? And couldn't Willowpelt be Sandstorm's mother? That would explain both Jaypaw's coloring as well as Lionpaw's.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Dawnfeatehr

I think that Stormfur will be leader of the Tribe of Rushing Water after Stoneteller. Reasons;

Remember what Stormfur said to Brambleclaw after he and Brook had been kicked out of RiverClan? Brambleclaw had been thinking about how if Hawkfrost had a reason behind it, however bad, and he was trying to achieve something, surely that made it right? That's what Tigerstar had taught him. He was pondering over his conflicted feelings when suddenly, Stormfur turned to him and said something like, " You have chosen the wrong path" or something like that. He was probably refering to Brambleclaw's thoughts, and they way he trusted Tigerstar. That is a quality of a Medicine Cat/ Leader / Teller of Pointed Stones. No oordinary cat can do that!

This is a really bad reason, but CAN YOU JUST IMAGINE THE LOOK ON STONETELLER'S FACE if he found out that his precious tribe would soon be in the hands of Stormfur, the cat he pronounced dead? (Remember, Stoneteller is old)

This is more of a reason against, but the stoneteller never leaves the cave. As we found out in Moonrise, Stormfur quite dislikes this. But his father, although a extremely decent cat, broke the Warrior code many a time. Maybe his son would change the code of the Tribe? It would make sense.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: Dawnfeather

It is just just too much of a coincidence that Lowbranch named Sky watcher Sky after Skystar because she had hopes for the future of her clan. I believe that Skystar and Skywatcher are the same cat, just re-encarnated, like Cinderpelt/heart. Skywatcher's life was dedicated to the moment whan his clan would be put back together, and he seemed to know it would happen, which is why he held onto life until he did.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory by: ?

Why I think Hollyleaf, Jayfeather and Lionblaze are Leafpool's and Crowfeather's kit's. Do not read unless you've read Long Shadows.

When Squirrelflight admits she's not the mother of Jayfeather, Hollyleaf and Lionblaze, who else would be their mother, but Leafpool? Skywatcher's prophecy says There will be three,kin of your kin who hold the power of the stars in their paws. If it's not Squirrelflight, it would be Leafpool 'cuz she's the only other kin of Firestar!(Unless Firestar and Sandstorm had a secret kit, which is highly unlikely)

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Silverflake

You all remember how fiercely Ashfur was fighting with Lionblaze when he asked for extra warrrior training.

Well I think it's because he was already planing to kill Squirrelflight's kits one by one and that was the perfect opportunity to start with Lionblaze. But after Firestar came, his plan was ruined. So he tried to kill them all together in the fire in Long shadows.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Skyfeather

In the preview for The Power Of Three: Sunrise it says "One warrior will be lost forever"

Some people think someone will die, well I think Hollyleaf becomes evil.

Proof:

On one of the Erin Hunter's blogs they say that one of the three will be evil. Most likely Holly.

In the preivew it also says someone she looks up to and admires and she has to turn on them. She was always proud that her "father" Brambleclaw was deputy.

She also probally has a lot of anger because squirrelflight.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Harepaw

Why Breezepelt is the Fourth Appertience:

- He is Firestar's grandson and literally "Kin of his kin", because he's Firestars son-in-law's kit.

-He is mentioned throughout POT, from rescueing the kits in the tunnels to going on the journey to the mountains with the Three. He's logically then very important, and who could be more important then the Fourth Appertience?

-On the front cover of Omen of the Stars 1 : The Fourth Appertience, there's a gray cat with green eyes, who looks suspiciously like Breezepelt's grandmother, Ashfoot.

- Hollyleaf is the thinker, Lionblaze is the fighter, Jayfeather is the seer. In COTC, it says (Breezepaw) "is what Onestar needs most....a warrior with complete faith they can win every battle" . Maybe Breezepelt is the believer? The Three have a disturbing lack of self-esteem...

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Harepaw

Who Killed Ashfur?

As anyone who read Long Shadows knows, the book ends with Ashfur being found dead in the water and Leafpool realizing it was foul play. Now, if you explain the book carefully, there are really just three suspects that could be his killer.

1. Squirrelflight: The obvious suspect. Squirrelflight has motive (Ashfur was about to reveal her biggest secret) , opportunity (she was late to the Gathering and covered in mud) and ablitiy (she's a gifted warrior and isn't afraid to do what she thinks is right). Also, when it was revealed that Ashfur was murdered, she has holding her breath like she was nervous. The one flaw to this theory is that Squirrelflight as the murderer is just too obvious, so I doubt Squirrelflight is the killer.

2. Leafpool: Think about it. If Ashfur had revealed Squirrelflights secret at the Gathering, then Thunderclan would have had to look into who the real mother of the Three was, and pretty soon someone would guess Leafpool. And they'd be more mad at Leafpool too, because she went againest the warrior code, wheras Squirrelflight just tried to help out her sister. And she has opportunity too, when the rest of the cats going to the Gathering were ready to go, she and Jayfeather were just approaching, even though their den is the closest. Ashfur was fond dead in the water-where Leafpool goes to collect herbs-and when Leafpool was sitting vigil for him, Jayfeather felt a rush of sadness coming from her. Maybe it was regret for what she had had to do?

3. Hollyleaf: I'm a little biased here, because I'm a strong proponent of the "Hollyleaf is evil" theory, but there's a lot of evidence for her as a suspect as well. When all three of "The Three" tried to persuade Ashfur not to reveal Squirrelflights secret, Hollyleaf was the angriest of the Three. The most important thing in the world to Hollyleaf is the warrior code-if she felt Ashfur was breaking it (which she did) how far would she go to protect it? Also Hollyleaf dreams of becoming Clan leader-how many cats would want a half-clan medicine cat kit to lead them?

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Silvermist

I believe that one of the three will become evil. the question is which one will it be?

*Jayfeather: I really don't think he will be the one because, he already turned down hawkfrost and tigerstar, i think that he has too much trust for spottedleaf and leafpool, and i think he has to much of a big part in the series.

*lionblaze: I think he would be more likely but, i don"t think he will be the one either because, he is starting to relize what tigerstar is doing to him. but, since they don't believe they are the three at the time so he might fall back to tigerstar.

*hollyleaf: Ithink she is the most likely to become evil just because, she is smart, if she made plans she would sucseed, also science she dose not have her power yet i think in sunrise she will get her power, and it will be POWERFUL she might use that to her advantage.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Cloverstar

Who Is The Fourth Apprentice? (MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS!)

1. Breezepelt- he is practically mentioned throughout the books (Power of Three).

2. Ivykit or Dovekit (not born yet)- I did a little research, and I found out that there are two kits (Ivykit and Dovekit), who are kin of Firestar. One of them has an ominous dream saying she posseses mystical skills unmatched by any cat. The cover is a gray cat- DOVEkit is most likely gray.

This may or may not be true.... what if one of the three has kits in Sunrise. Jayfeather can't because he's a medicine cat, so that leaves Lionblaze or Hollyleaf. Hollyleaf is on the cover of Sunrise. The fourth apprentice will be revealed on the last line of Sunrise. What if Hollyleaf mates with Mousewhisker? He is gray and white, so maybe Dovekit inherits her colors from him.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Firestorm

Tigerstar, he's visited the dreams of every single cat of the Three so far(and thanks to the last book, we know why Holly never showed a power or had a visit from Tigerstar- which I'm kind of surprised about because of her ambitions.) he probably WILL visit the dreams of the next cat, Dovekit or Ivykit, depending on who it is.

And why is Tigerstar so interested in the three? If they really have the power of the stars in their paws, then what if Tigerstar thinks they can bring him back to life? We know he can physically hurt the living so maybe he could come back? So he's trying to get the trust and loyalty of at least one of the three hoping that that one would convince the others to help him or try it on their own. But so far, its backfired. Spottedleaf intervened with Jayfeather, and Lionblaze finally realized that he was doing the wrong thing and ditched him. He has to visit the next cat in the prophecy and I'm sure that it will affect the plot big time.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Wildstream

WARNING DO NOT READ UNLESS YOU HAVE READ SUNRISE- THEORIES FOR THE FOURTH APPRENTICE!!!

I think that Dovekit will be the third cat in the prophecy because of Dove's Wing, in the ancient clan. One of my friends reminded me during our speculations that each of the three had been reincarnated so I think that Dovekit is the reincarnated Dove's Wing.As well as the fact that Dove kit is on the cover of the fourth apprentice meaning that she will be imortant to the story

I also think that Dovekit's and Ivykit's relationship will be like that of Squirrelflight and Leafpool, but I have no Idea what that could lead to

It also sounds like leafpool has resigned as ThunderClan's medicen cat and if Dovekit (or Ivykit) is having prophetic dreams than maybe she'll be a medicen cat apprentice

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: a fan

Dovekit will be the fourth and Ivykit will be Holly's replacement. I think Dove will become Jayfeather's apprentice and Ivy will be Lionblaze's. When they find out about the prophecy, Ivy is really hurt that she is just a replacement. She might wanna turn on Dove, but won't. We've had enough traitors. Then Holly comes back-ALIVE and good again!! She meets Ivy and there's a problem-who is the real prophecy cat? Crowfeather will get closer to his kits and will fall in love with Leafpool again. AND wouldnt it be awesome if Tawnypelt's kits were in the middle of THEIR OWN prophecy? AND I think Breezepelt and Lionblaze will get in a fight and Lion will kill Breeze. Crow and Nightcloud become devestated, but Crow still loves Lion. And I think Crow and Jay will soon get really close, and Jay will form a sorta big-brother-little-sister relationship. Dove will be an incredible medicine cat and Ivy will be an amazing fighter. So...you can disagree but I think at least some of this will happen.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Fishy

Many fans have been saying Hollyleaf will, "Come back and be sane again and will help the prophecy". I'm positive that this theory is not true for many reasons...

Sunset, page 314: Although the book never DIRECTLY stated that Holleyleaf was crushed and KILLED, she most definetly was. In the book it says the river had hit the walls because it was high and had collapse. Jayfeather also said he could picture her body hitting the floor, and getting crush. Plus, I think they would have heard her jump into the river. And even if she did, the walls would have still fallen on her while she was floating downstream. The tunnel created by the river would have collapsed, too.

Sunset, page 313: It states that Hollyleaf is very upset. I one point she says, "'I know I did the right thing, but no cat will ever understand'". She obiously didn't just go into the tunnel for "alone time". She went in there to kill herself because her whole world was shattered.

The first book in the fourth Warriors ark, as everyone knows, is called "The Fourth Apprentence". People who belive that Holleyleaf is coming back say that either Dovekit or Ivykit (only one of them) will become the fourth apprentence. along with Hollyleaf when she returns. I belive that, because Hollyleaf is dead, Dovekit AND Ivykit will become these "fourth apprentences". This can be proven because in the back of Sunset, there is a small preview for the first book, and it says, "Soon, one sister will have an ominous dream-- and will realize that she possesses mystical skills unmatched by any other cat". This means either Dovekit or Ivykit WILL BECOME PART OF THE THREE-- Hollyleaf is gone. Dead. She is useless in the prophecy. How would she "help" anyways?

Why would Hollyleaf want to come back in the first place? She's already insane, and seriously screwed up her clan. If she was alive, she'd probably either attempt to kill herself again or become a loner.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Mistclaw

Why I believe that Hollyleaf is still alive

We were in Jayfeather’s point of view, Jayfeather imagined that he saw his sister being knocked to the ground and being buried, but we didn’t see it.

While they were morning Hollyleaf they said that there was no body to morn

Hollyleaf could easily escape the tunnels; she could swim through the river and into the lake and could be hiding somewhere.

The first book in the new series is called the fourth apprentice, coincidence? It said that one sister would have strange dreams, so either Ivykit or Dovekit is the fourth in the prophecy, Hollyleaf might still have powers, still making her part of the prophecy

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Hawkfire of Nightclan

In the Fourth Apprentice, it will probably be Dovekit who's part of the prophecy.

I have heard that Toadkit will be Jayfeather's apprentice...that would be nice.

It's also possible that it could be Ivykit who's in the prophecy, but there is already a cat in Shadowclan with first part of name "Ivy", so that might not be good.

But my theory on power? Well, Jayfeather can read thoughts and Lionblaze can fight, so I think this cat will have hunting skills. But skills so they could detect where every single animal on the territory was. So in case of an invasion, the third cat finds out where the enemy is, Jayfeather figures out the best strategy based on what they're thinking, and Lionblaze chases them away.

That's what I think will happen!

--------------------------------------------------------

Thoery By: Leopardeyes

Hey Warrior fans I just came up with this crazy plot twist for OMotS!! Okay here it is:

One night I was thinkin about Warriorz and suddenly this crazy idea came to me- what if Crowfeather somehow accedentally killed Nightcloud?? Okay I know it's insane but what if Leafpool tries to talk to Crowy about the kits and Night attacks her? So, what if Crow tries to stop his mate and accedentally KILLS Nightcloud? Then what? Onestar banishes him of course! But only for six or somethin moons bcuz it wasn't intetional. Then, Crowfeather goes to ThunderClan because he has nowhere else to go. Firestar accepts and Crow becomes more and more attatched to Leaf again, who now doesn't have a rank. What if he gets really close to Jayfeather and Lionblaze too? That would be awesome! Then when it's time to go home Crowfeather will hafta to choose- go back to WindClan or stay with his new family. That would be a huge twist and I have no idea what will happen! Also, a lot of people have been saying that Toadkit will be Jay's apprentice. Well, personally I hope it's Dovekit and Lionblaze could train Ivykit.

One vary last thing! Altho its more of a rant. There have been a LOT of people saying that Heathertail is really Hawkfrost's and Squirrelflight's kit for these reasons:

1. she has ice-blue eyes

2. when she and Lion created DarkClan she called him LionCLAW. it could have been in honor of her grandfather Tigerstar's warrior name

3. she's a snot like Squirrel

4. she's kinda ambitious like Hawk

Well...here are my problems with that:

1. Heather has STORMY PURPLE-ISH BLUE EYES

2. she's in WindClan and wouldn't have known about Tigerstar or his warrior name

3. totally agree with this one but having kinda the same personalities doesn't really mean aything

4. aren't all apprentices ambitious to be great warriors? and aren't all warriors ambitious to be loyal to their Clan?

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Hawkfire

Tigerstar, Scourage and Firestar are half brothers!

Pinestar was ginger and he ran away to be a kittypet. Since he is ThunderClan, he would have great spirit like Quince said. Erin Hunter did say that Scourage and Firestar are half brothers and Firestar has mentioned his nephews for the whole series.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Swiftpaw7

In Sunrise, I had the feeling that Hollyleaf was evil. Well, maybe she got her evilness form Brackenfur. And Lionblaze from Ashfur. And Hollyleaf really doesn't have a special talent.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Swiftpaw7

Well, if the three were children of Leafpool then it would be kin of your kin for Tigerstar. Because Squirrelflight is kind of Tigerstar's kin even though there's no evidence that she married Bramble. But then Jay, Lion, and Holly are pretty much Squirrelflight's kin. So it's "kin of your kin" for Tigerstar too.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Sagepaw

Who Firestar's Father is

I think Firestar's father is a kittypet named Jake. Here is why:

1. He has a flame colored pelt.

2. He is a kittypet

3. In Bluestar's prophecy he is mentioned A LOT so I think that may mean something.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: a Fan

I've seen a few theories about how Scorge's mother is also Firestars, and i wanted to add to that theory...

1) Scorge's father is also Firestars, but they have different mothers, like maybe Firestar's is Violet, which explains Princess's markings.

2) It msy be far-fetched, but maybe Ruby is Firestar's mother! She could have markings like Princess's, and she could of carried the ginger-colored gene that her father had! Everyone carries genes, and some genes skip generations. Like my grandfather is colorblind, but his sons arent. But my brother, is. Get it?

3) To further theory #2, maybe Barley is his father! He's old enough of course, and that explains Princess's markings! 4) Ok totally out there, but maybe that kittypet Bluestar ( Bluefur at the time) met was Firestar's father! Why else would Erin Hunter include it in the story?

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Cat Bucky

Mabye, just mabye, Pinestar is Firstar's father. He seems to have great understanding of the clans, right from the start! Resons its possible...

1. Pinestar became a kittypet.

2. Firestar seems to like the outdoors. (As a kittypet.)

3. Pinestar was orange. I think...

4. I'm pretty sure Pinstar had green eyes.

5. Tigerstar and Firestar are related...Wait, thats not a reson.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: A Fan

Was Bluestar just greiving for just Redtail or Oakheart too?

Since Tigerclaw said that he killed Oakheart did that have anything to do with his delay in being deputy?

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Briarthorn

Sorry for the spoilers everyone, but I've read Sunrise. It turns out that Hollyleaf was never part of the Three at all. But there is one prophecy that talks about a "JAY," "LION" & "DOVE!" I'm guessing that means Dovekit/Dovepaw will be part of the Three! Let's see if my prediction comes true!

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Briarthorn

I'm not sure who Firestar's parents are, but the choices do makes since. Okay, so Scourge MIGHT be Firestar's half-brother, right? And he killed him. But Scourge was EVIL! And guess who else was evil? Hollyleaf. She was black, too. I know Crowfeather was black, but Scourge was too, and if Scourge is in fact related to Firestar, then part of Scourge's black pelt gene could gave skipped Leafpool & Squirrelflight and interfered with Hollyleaf, strengthning her black coat.

--------------------------------------------------------

Theory By: Riverfire

I have a Theory about Sky. Here it is:

Well, in Code Of the Clans, it says something like, "Wind, Shadow, Thunder, River, and SKY." Sky? Well, in Firestar's Quest, it has Sky. He seemed to have a lot of nowledge about SkyClan, though. Was Sky possablaly SkyClan's Leader before Leafdapple?

Was he clinging to his last life to make sure the Clan that was destroyed was rebuilt? Also, another reason I think this is because he was the first rogue Firestar and Sandstorm met, right? Plus, in the Prolougue in Firestar's Quest, it says SkySTAR. This is why I beleive Sky is actually the first leader of SkyClan

--------------------------------------------------------

Back To Top

Please note: Anything I place on this site runs the risk of being stolen/used without permission. Although I do have message and rules about this, Warrior Cat Pics/ Moonclaw will NOT be Responsible if your Video/Image/Story is stolen)